Advertisements
Skip to content

Property prices affected due to LRT 3 cancellations? (6 stations)

Posted in HSR MRT n other Ts

Did the news of the cancellations of LRT 3 stations affected you? Perhaps worried if the property prices would drop due to this new development? Anyway, the cost was one main issue why some of these stations were axed. These are the six stations which will not be constructed. Anyway, with regards to the worry of falling property prices, according to some experts, the cancellations will not affect the property prices.  Here’s that full article in edgeprop.my: Here’s why prices of properties near the shelved LRT 3 stations won’t tumble.

Image Source: Edgeprop.my

Comments by Nawawi Tie Leung managing director Eddy Wong. He said that he believed that the government has done a cost-and-benefit analysis, which showed that removing these stations will not have a huge impact as these areas may not have a lot of commuters. He added, “I would say that the scrapping out of the six LRT stations will have an impact, but what we need to look at is the magnitude of the impact. The stations are not built yet [so it is not physically there], it is not like the stations were built and then now taken out.”

According to the Malaysian Institute of Estate Agents (MIEA) president-elect Lim Boon Ping also agrees that it will not cause a tumble in property prices but perhaps just some disappointment to the local communities who were expecting a station near their homes. He added, “It won’t have a big impact as it’s not something which is already built and being removed. Furthermore, people who want to use the LRT will still have other options, such as going to another station or choosing the park and ride.”

Metro Homes Sdn Bhd director See Kok Loong said that the impact will be for projects catering to the rental market. He added, “[For the properties that were banking on the stations], it means they have lost a unique selling point and thus their prices might adjust accordingly in the secondary market.”

As for the impact on housing price, Wong from Nawawi Tie Leung said, “Usually, a 700m to 800m is the average distance one will be willing to walk to reach the station, so properties around here will be impacted more in terms of price. However, what these properties really lose are their potential gains – which range from about 5% to 10% – from their proximity to the stations. “So, what we will see is just that there will not be a capital appreciation of 5% to 10% for the properties surrounding these stations.”

Rahim & Co International Sdn Bhd (Petaling Jaya) director Choy Yue Kwong says that the key to the LRT3’s popularity is the last-mile connection. “If the shuttle bus system could be improved and well-coordinated to shorten the waiting time, people will be more willing to take public transport than drive.” He added, “Although six stations have been shelved, as long as the provision or flexibility for future extension is still there, I believed it will not have a significant impact to the existing developments along LRT3.” Here’s the full article in edgeprop.my for reference. 

Personally, I think it’s more important to realise that property prices will change only when there’s actual transactions. Do we believe those owners who own properties nearby these cancelled stations would now immediately drop their prices by 10 percent simply because those stations are no longer going to be built? If the answer is YES, then the owners must be desperate sellers. If that’s the case, the LRT station cancellations was not the main reason for the drop in price. If the answer is NO, there you have it, the property prices will not be changing much in the near future. In fact, when we put in the inflation equation plus the salary increments, the property prices will definitely be inching upwards. The only unknown might be the actual percent that the prices will increase. Happy believing and please do not make LRT 3 stations as your ONLY reason to buy such a property and paying a high premium for it yeah. Property investment is for the long term and well, 2024 is at least 6 years away.

written on 15 July 2018

Next suggested article: Bangsar South back to Kerinchi, property prices to drop?

Advertisements

2 Comments

  1. fongkh
    fongkh

    I personally thinkn that this would affect the developer sales indeed especially those unsold units. Those bought over the property with banking on LRT3 station will also piss off due to the news. Eighter they already paid high price for that factored in the proximity of the LRT station. For the developer, the project is usually get very high plot ratio and of course this all come to a cost hence selling price is always higher as premium attached. Those new projects with unsold units will be absolutely affected. A longer time is needed for them to unload. and those already paid for high price, sorry for that but still, another station is just nearby though.

    July 15, 2018
    |Reply
    • kopiandproperty.com
      kopiandproperty.com

      Very true. I think it will take a much longer time because even the timeline has changed to 2024. I do not think there are any new launches today with a complation year of 2024 today. Perhaps at max maybe 2022?

      July 15, 2018
      |Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: